Real learning takes place when an individual is interested, motivated, and is challenged. Throw a child into a classroom where they feel unsafe, disinterested, and bored, and you will have little learning. The burden of creating a productive learning environment is mostly in the hands of the classroom teacher.
Create high interest materials and lessons for an exciting topic, and throw in an ill-equipped teacher, and there is no learning.
Now some may say, "Fine. At least my child (student) has the "class" on their report card/transcript and teachers/colleges/employers will.....
Hold on for a second. Have employers looked at your transcript? Do you remember your AP or Honors class?
Probably not. It's just the surface of learning. As a teacher within the maze of education, it's all about learning. It's a waste of my time to debate it. Students who learn are people who grow, change, and become a better person after they leave a lesson, unit, or my classroom. That's all that life's about...changing and growing and becoming better at what we do, say, think, etc.
So while it may look good on a transcript, it was mostly a complete waste of time for the person who went through it if there was a better alternative.
So what's my suggestion? This is insider information. But beware! Authorities will deny everything. I would too if I was one, but that's why I'm not, because "I cannot tell a lie!" Still, it is complex and not 100%, but here are a few ideas.
- Find out about the new crop of teachers in the grade above. Stop by their room, look at their website, get to know them. And then when it's time to select classes, talk to the guidance counselor/principal and push for that certain team of teachers/teacher that would offer the best learning opportunities for your child. Of course if you have no valid information, just continue letting the bureaucracy pick your child's teachers for you.
- You would truly be interested if you learned that your child is placed with a certain group of fellow students based on abilities, rather than mixed grouping. No one will tell you, but in my limited experience of four schools, it was shockingly clear. Every teacher gets a high, medium, and low class. There are other scenarios but such is scheduling. No one will admit to this, but it's happening.
- Do you want your child with more engaging teachers? Keep the child out of the low classes. How do you do that? By having them play an instrument! Band kids generally have higher IQ's and also have to be grouped for this "special" class. They tend to stick together across different classes. The same occurs for high level math classes. Since this one class is offered at one time, students are forced into a tight schedule for their other core classes and it's usually with the same "high" level students.
- Many times in middle school, there are a number of "teams." One team has the high level math class(es). Get your child moved to this team and generally the students will be higher level, more motivated, and their teachers will have to keep pace.
- Take your child out of "high" level classes and get them into the middle ones. The rationale for this is that low classes tend to have students who have serious motivation/organization/academic skills. If they need more help with these areas, they should be there! But, if they are placed in the higher level classes, a number of negative factors may come into play:
- many teachers are not qualified or trained to teach high-level students. The result is a lot of busy work, rather than in-depth work.
- many veteran and experienced teachers try to avoid high-level courses because of the parents. Some of the parents are very involved in their child's education but are following the theory that their children are one of the "privileged" and deserve high grades. Worksheets provide high grades, true learning is dangerous, and parents don't always want their child to have low grades; hence, the materials and instruction are not cutting-edge. To sum up, the best teachers move away from cookie-cutter classes like honors and AP, and in Virginia, SOL testing grades like 3,5,8 because their is more freedom for real learning in other grades and classes.
- many students in high-level classes are very busy after school with social/sports events more so than other classes. This realistically reduced the amount of potential and upward mobility of the class throughout the year. Students in the low and mid-level groups will tend to grow more and develop a more positive academic attitude and work ethic. Teachers are aware of this and cannot/or are forced to give less demanding work than they should.
- The classes that most teachers brag about are the ones in the middle: the students ready to learn who work hard. We tend to get frustrated with the low classes that struggle with study skills, memorizing, organization issues, personal problems. We get frustrated with the high-level students who consistently underachieve and are pushed by their parents to unrealistic heights. But we enjoy and work very hard with all of them and appreciate the opportunity to help each one in their academic and personal journey.




